The Fifth Victim
EpisodeS1E259 min2025-08-10

The Yogurt Shop Murders

The Fifth Victim

After years of false leads and wrongful arrests, new investigators take over the case and revisit a key interrogation video.

My Thoughts
Guest Stars
Special appearances in this episode.

Guest Stars

John Jones

Self - Lead Investigator

Mike Huckabay

Self - Homicide Investigator

Reese Price

Self - Yogurt Shop Manager

Sonora Thomas

Self - Eliza's Sister

Shawn Ayers

Self - Amy's Brother

Bob Ayers

Self - Amy's Father

Pam Ayers

Self - Amy's Mother (archive footage)

Erin Moriarty

Self - Correspondent, 48 Hours

Forrest Welborn

Self - Suspect (archive foorage)

Maurice Pierce

Self - Suspect (archive foorage)

Crew
Episode-specific crew credits.
Margaret Brown

Margaret Brown

Director

Directing

MB

Michael Bloch

Editor

Editing

TH

Tyler H. Walk

Editor

Editing

Videos
Clips and promos for this episode.

Videos

No videos available.

Stills
Episode still images from TMDB.

Stills

Still

3840 × 2160