02.05.02 - Tuesday: Secrets

When Chris confronts Amy about stealing his photo, Amy proposes that in return for sex, Chris stop investigating her past and he agrees. When Rafe offers profound advice to Livvie, Alison suspects he knows Kevin will die. Ali prays in the chapel, then cries over her breakup with Jamal. Ian and Eve continue arguing about his unorthodox treatment of Kevin. Paige encourages Kevin to cross over to the ""other side,"" while on Earth, Lucy pleads with him to stay with the living. Hearing her pleas, Kevin tells Paige it doesn't feel right to go with her, then opens his eyes and reunites with his family as Paige looks in on them.